I Tried 20 Store-Bought Guacamole, and Here Are the Best Ones

A chunky dip for spice lovers, a classic for purists, a wild card, and more.

7 Nov 2023

5 min read

*This article includes mentions of merchants or brands who are partners of DoorDash, and DoorDash may receive a commission if you choose to make a purchase from these merchants or brands.

I’m a trained cook and recipe developer. When it comes to guacamole, my general philosophy is “more is more.”

This ethos holds true whether I’m dining out in Pittsburgh or hosting friends in my own kitchen. But let’s be honest: I’m not making multiple varieties from scratch. Instead, I like to go the store-bought route for dips, which frees me up to arrange the crudité and get the house tidied up for guests. Of course, not all packaged guacs are created equal. To find the very best, I turned to DoorDash.

THE METHODOLOGY

I ordered every single variety in my delivery radius, which added up to more than 20. I omitted “just-add” packets, guacamole salsas, and anything labeled “avocado mash.”

I then invited a few discerning friends over for a taste test: Tierney, who owns a luxury picnic company and knows her way around an appetizer spread; her husband, Tyler, who loves nothing more than a tableside guac preparation; and Ally, an on-the-go pediatric resident who’s no stranger to single-serve guac containers.

We tasted the guacamole on their own, with carrot and celery sticks, and finally with tortilla chips. Ultimately, we agreed on a clear top tier.

THE RESULTS

The Best Overall: Sabra Guacamole Classic

Even after sampling my weight in guacamole, I kept dipping my chip into this classic version. The crowd-pleasing dip is flavored with lime juice, salt, and cilantro and studded with fresh onion, garlic, tomato, and jalapeño (though it’s only mildly spicy). Unlike some of its competitors, its citrusy, slightly tangy flavor isn’t artificial or overpowering, and its chunky texture makes it taste the most like it was homemade. (Ally mentioned a lot of other guacamole we tried were so smooth they seemed “whipped,” which is why we were into the natural texture of this one.) I’ll be hitting “reorder” on this one for sure. Because it’s so flavorful, it’s perfect for dipping straight.

The Best Mild: Good & Gather Classic Guacamole

This attractive dip has a smooth, hummus-like texture and a complex, garlicky flavor. I appreciate its short ingredient list — there are no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives — and its lack of both tomato and cilantro means it appeals to pickier guests. Use it to add an instant boost of flavor to tacos, quesadillas, or a sheet pan of loaded nachos.

The Best Spicy: Good & Gather Homestyle Guacamole

Technically, this guacamole is labeled “medium heat.” But it has a significant kick — thanks to serrano peppers — that’s sure to satisfy spice heads. There are chunks of avocado, tomatoes, and onions in every bite, making it particularly well-suited for a scoop-shaped tortilla chip. And whereas some of its competitors relied on the saltiness of the chips, this one is so well-seasoned (with cilantro and garlic, in addition to the salt) that it can hold its own with raw veggies, too.

The Wildcard: Park Street Deli Pineapple Poblano Restaurant-Style Guacamole

If you’re looking to liven up your appetizer spread, this guacamole is just the ticket. The sweetness of the pineapple balances the earthy flavor of the roasted poblanos — when scooped onto chips, you get sweet, savory, and salty all at once. The addition of poblanos keeps it from being too sweet (this guacamole doesn’t skimp on the pineapple), but it’s by no means spicy, making it a great pick for the kids. I can see this being a staple for build-your-own taco nights and the solution to getting the kids to eat their carrot sticks. (One can dream!)

A final tip: It’s worth noting that all of the guacamole fell victim to browning after a few days in the fridge, so it’s best to use ’em up quickly. Serve them at a party, bring them to a potluck, or pile them into a seven-layer dip. And if you say they’re homemade, we won’t tell.

Want more? Check out the best hummus, salsa, and dips!

Shop Grocery

PHOTO CREDIT:

Photographer: Paul Quitoriano
Art Direction: Sarah Ceniceros Gomez

Topics

Football Party Tailgate Check Out Home & Entertaining

Author

Grace Elkus

Guac lovers, rejoice: store-bought guacamole has come a long way, and it’s easier than ever to find a version that delivers on flavor, texture, and freshness. Whether you like yours smooth and simple, chunky and citrusy, or packed with heat and bold seasoning, there’s a style out there that matches your dip-night vibe. Skip the extra grocery run and browse guacamole and other pantry essentials from nearby stores on DoorDash, then have everything delivered straight to your couch-side chip bowl.

Frequently Asked Questions about Ordering Groceries on DoorDash

You can get nearly anything you need delivered through DoorDash Grocery — from fresh produce (like avocados, tomatoes, and herbs) to pantry staples, dairy, frozen foods, snacks, and even specialty items like store-bought guacamole. Whether you’re grabbing ingredients for tacos, stocking up the freezer, or just topping off essentials for the week, you’ll find a wide selection at your fingertips. It’s all about convenience: browse, tap, and your groceries show up at your door, ready to use — no extra trips needed.

Yes — DoorDash Grocery often offers organic and specialty options for items like avocados, guacamole, and other fresh produce or ready-to-eat items. Many grocery partners list both conventional and organic varieties, and some even carry small-batch or gourmet guacamole brands. Whether you’re looking for classic flavors, organic produce, or specialty dips, you’ll be able to find them through DoorDash — all delivered straight to your door.

DoorDash keeps your perishable groceries fresh by having top-rated shoppers pick items like avocados, dairy, and refrigerated goods toward the end of their shop and handle them with extra care. Cold items are packed separately to maintain temperature, and once your order is ready, a Dasher delivers it quickly—often in as little as 30 minutes*—so everything arrives crisp, chilled, and ready to eat. The entire experience is designed to feel as reliable as shopping for yourself, just with the convenience of having your groceries show up right at your door.

*Delivery times vary by location. See app for estimate.

Our taste test highlighted several standout guacamole brands, each offering something a little different. Sabra delivers a smooth, classic flavor that’s easy to pair with chips or tacos, while Good & Gather’s Classic Guacamole leans mild and crowd-friendly with a clean, simple ingredient list. For something bolder, Good & Gather Homestyle (Medium Heat) brings a chunkier texture with a serrano-pepper kick, and Park Street Deli’s Pineapple Poblano adds a sweet-savory twist that’s great for people who like a little adventure in their dip. These options make it easy to find a guac that fits your style.

Many grocery partners on DoorDash let you link your store loyalty account so you can earn points or access member-only deals on your orders. When a retailer supports it, you’ll see an option to connect during checkout or on the store’s page — then eligible discounts and loyalty rewards are applied automatically.

Groceries from nearby stores often arrive fast — many DoorDash Grocery orders reach you in as little as 30 minutes*, depending on store location and Dasher availability. Because we work with local grocers and trusted shoppers who pick and pack efficiently, your items spend minimal time in transit. That means produce, frozen foods, dairy, and pantry staples all stay fresh and ready for use. Whether you’re grabbing a quick meal fix or doing a full restock, speed and convenience are part of every order.

*Delivery times vary by location. See app for estimate.

If your guacamole or any grocery item arrives damaged, incorrect, or not up to expectations, you can quickly report the issue via the DoorDash app. Go to your order details, tap Help, and select the option that matches what went wrong—whether it’s a missing item, damaged packaging, or something not as described. DoorDash’s Quality Guarantee covers grocery orders, so you can request a refund or replacement right away. This gives you peace of mind that your order will be taken care of, even if things don’t go perfectly.

Yes—you can schedule your grocery delivery for a specific day or time using DoorDash. When you reach checkout, you’ll see available delivery windows and you can pick one that fits your schedule. That means you can plan ahead if you know you’ll be home later or want everything to arrive before dinner. It’s a handy way to lock in groceries for a busy week or make sure fresh items don’t sit too long before you get home.

Yes — with DoorDash Grocery, you can often add forgotten items even after you’ve checked out, as long as your shopper hasn’t finished assembling your order yet. Just open the app, go to your active order, and look for an “Add Items” option. If it’s available, you can search for what you forgot—guacamole, snacks, produce, whatever you need—and add it on the fly. It’s an easy way to avoid a second trip and make sure you’re grabbing everything you need in one go.

Local neighborhood grocers on DoorDash can offer delivery times that are just as fast as larger stores, especially if they’re close to your home. Wherever you order from, your order is picked and delivered by Dashers active in your area, which helps keep timing consistent across stores.